NSW Underquoting Laws: An Eleventh-Hour Reversal That's Hardly a Vote Winner

17 November 2026 Real Estate

NSW Underquoting Laws: An Eleventh-Hour Reversal That's Hardly a Vote Winner

Real estate agent holding property auction brochure

Just hours before NSW's new underquoting laws were due to come into effect, Premier Chris Minns announced they were being put on hold. Apparently, conversations with real estate agents in his own electorate had persuaded him that aspects of the legislation were problematic.

The result? Buyers will now have to wait until December 2027 for reforms that were supposed to make property pricing more transparent.

Truly bizarre.

Underquoting has been an issue in Sydney's property market for years, and if you've ever bought or sold property, you'll likely know this to be true. While many agents insist they don't underquote, I've encountered enough examples to know it's a very real problem.

I've heard price guides quoted at inspections that are significantly below what those same properties sold for just a few years earlier. Now, in this softening market, there may be occasions when an owner must sell at a loss. But this underquoting was happening long before the current downturn.

For buyers, the consequences are very real. They give up their Saturdays to inspect properties, and when they find one they want to pursue, they do their due diligence — sometimes paying for building and pest inspections and contract reviews — only to discover that the vendor's expectations are nowhere near the price they've been quoted.

It's frustrating, expensive and a complete waste of everyone's time. But if you wonder why agents underquote, put simply — they get feet through the door at inspections, numbers to call on Monday and the opportunity for a real case of FOMO to set in among buyers who may be looking well above their budget.

What is underquoting?

For those unfamiliar with the term, underquoting is when a selling agent advertises a property or quotes a price to prospective buyers that's below the agent's estimated selling price recorded in their agreement with the vendor.

In other words, the agent is suggesting a property could sell for less than their own assessment of its likely selling price.

But buyers don't get to see that agreement, so how are they supposed to know whether the price they're being quoted complies with the law?

Underquoting is already illegal in NSW, but proving it can be notoriously difficult. An agent can argue that the price guide was revised following market feedback or increased buyer interest. NSW Fair Trading says it will continue monitoring compliance, including at open homes and auctions. But the fact that underquoting remains a compliance priority tells us this is still an issue that needs addressing.

What was supposed to change?

The new legislation, passed in June and due to commence today,  17 November 2026, was intended to bring some much-needed transparency to the buying process. The changes were:

  • Adding a selling price or price range in residential property advertisements — the days of "price on inquiry" would be over.
  • Requiring online ads to be updated within one business day if a displayed price no longer complies with the law — for example, if the estimated selling price is revised, a written offer is rejected because it's too low, or the property is passed in at auction.
  • Using the three most comparable sales when setting or revising an estimated selling price.
  • Keeping detailed records showing how an estimated selling price was determined.
  • Increasing penalties for underquoting up to $110,000 or three times an agent's commission, whichever is greater.

All perfectly reasonable. I'd go so far as to suggest the reforms could have gone further.

So why the sudden backflip?

One particular provision seems to have caused concern. Under the proposed rules, an agent would not have been permitted to advertise a property below an offer that the vendor had previously rejected.

For example, a vendor rejects an offer of $1.5 million. A month later, the property hasn't sold and the vendor is now prepared to accept $1.45 million. The legislation would prevent the agent from advertising at that lower price. Markets change, as do vendors' circumstances.

So why couldn't Minns have amended that particular provision rather than putting the entire package of reforms on hold?

Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong has defended the decision on the grounds that the legislation was passed in a different economic and housing market. The Government is using the softening market to justify leaving things as they are.

"People are already doing it tough, and the last thing we want is for laws designed to protect home buyers to inadvertently make it harder for them to buy a home."

Why would they?

Surely legislation governing property transactions should be designed to accommodate all market conditions? In fact, I'd argue that greater transparency becomes even more important in a falling market, when vendors' expectations and buyers' assessments of value can be further apart.

If an agent needs to reduce a price guide because the market has softened, then reduce it. That's perfectly reasonable, provided the revised guide is genuine and supported by evidence.

These laws had been in the pipeline for months, with extensive industry consultation. Yet apparently it took a few conversations with agents in the Premier's Kogarah electorate, just before the laws were due to commence, for this issue to be recognised. And then a complete backflip.

NSW goes to the polls on 13 March 2027. The underquoting reforms, originally due to commence in November 2026, have now been postponed until 1 December 2027 — well after the election.

It's all politics and who has the influence, of course.

These reforms were designed to protect buyers. Yet the people who appear to have had the Premier's ear at the eleventh hour were the very agents whose conduct the legislation was intended to regulate.

Who exactly is this decision supposed to please?

With a NSW election just four months away, I find the politics of this decision almost as baffling as the decision itself. Who exactly does Premier Minns think he's winning over?

Some real estate agents may be celebrating, but what about the thousands of buyers across NSW who have been waiting for greater transparency in the property market?

Does he seriously think first-home buyers, families and downsizers will welcome the news that reforms designed to protect them have been postponed until December 2027, nearly nine months after the state election?

I struggle to see the political logic.

And let's not forget that vendors are consumers too. Plenty of homeowners want a transparent, properly regulated industry.

Some prominent selling agents support greater transparency. In an article published by Domain on 17 November, Cary Giezekamp of The Agency Inner West said he would continue publishing price guides despite the postponement. John McGrath also expressed support for mandatory price guides and tougher action against agents who mislead buyers.

So this isn't even a case of the entire industry opposing the reforms.

What I found rather telling about the Domain article, however, was that while several selling agents were interviewed about the government's backflip, there wasn't a single buyer or buyers agent quoted.

Meanwhile, across the border...

What's particularly interesting is that Victoria has gone in the opposite direction. From 1 October this year, Victorian agents have been required to disclose the vendor's reserve price seven days before auction, along with providing buyers with information about comparable sales and the eventual selling price. greater property price transparency for Victorian homebuyers.

Imagine that. Buyers actually being told what the vendor wants before turning up to an auction.

Meanwhile, in NSW, we're postponing reforms that don't even go as far as Victoria's until December 2027.

It really does beg the question: whose interests are being prioritised here?

Buying property shouldn't require mind-reading skills

Buying property in Sydney has always involved guesswork, and it will remain so until at least the end of next year. In many overseas markets, properties are advertised with an asking price. You know what the vendor is asking, even if you ultimately negotiate a different figure.

Here in Sydney, we're accustomed to agents giving us a 'price guide', which may bear little resemblance to what the vendor wants. Often they won't give you a price at all.

And that's precisely what the new underquoting reforms were supposed to address.

Shouldn't I be happy about this backflip?

You could argue that, as a buyers agent, I should be delighted that the property market remains so lacking in transparency. After all, the more confusing and frustrating the buying process becomes, the more reason people have to engage someone like me to help them navigate it.

But that's not how I operate. I care above all about what's in the best interests of buyers.

There's far more to my role than assessing price guides, of course. I research, assess, negotiate and guide buyers through the entire process. But I would much rather work in a property market where buyers can trust the information they're being given.

And quite honestly, when there are no recent comparable sales to go on, it can get tiresome having to be a mindreader myself.

Surely it's time we stopped accepting this as normal.

Keys to Sydney

Judith Treanor — Independent Buyers Agent and Relocation Consultant specialising in Sydney's Inner West, Lower North Shore, and beyond.

I'm here for the buyers.

Area Focus

Inner West

Annandale

Ashfield

Balmain

Balmain East

Birchgrove

Burwood

Canada Bay

Drummoyne

Dulwich Hill

Five Dock

Forest Lodge

Glebe

Haberfield

Leichhardt

Lewisham

Lilyfield

Marrickville

Newtown

Rozelle

Russell Lea

Summer Hill

& more

Lower North Shore

Cammeray

Chatswood

Cremorne

Crows Nest

Gladesville

Kirribilli

Lane Cove

Lavender Bay

McMahons Point

Milsons Point

Mosman

Neutral Bay

North Sydney

Northbridge

Roseville

St Leonards

Waverton

Willoughby

Wollstonecraft

& more

Get in Touch

© 2026 Keys to Sydney — Judith Treanor. All Rights Reserved. Licensed Buyers Agent.